Jane Godman Author
  • Home
  • News
  • Bookshelf
  • About Jane
  • Blog

What would Drusilla do?

4/27/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
“You would become disgusted with my odious common-sense. Try as I will, I cannot be romantic!” said Miss Morville despairingly.
My recent post, 'Which Heyer Heroine Are You?' attracted considerable interest. Most people (myself included) fell somewhere between Mary Challoner (Devil’s Cub) and Judith Taverner (Regency Buck). Very few people felt identified with Leonie de St Vire, which is probably a good thing. If you’ve read ‘These Old Shades’, you’ll understand that comment.  Lovable as Leonie is between the pages of a book, you wouldn’t want her running loose with a sword or a gun.
I loved the suggestion that most of us would probably like to be the Marquesa de Villacanas (The Grand Sophy)! But the heroine many people felt they had most in common with was Drusilla Morville (The Quiet Gentleman).
I have a confession to make here, but there are mitigating circumstances (honest, guv). To my shame, when I first read The Quiet Gentleman, I did not recognise Drusilla as the heroine. When it dawned on me that this staid, dumpy, little figure was, indeed, going to turn out to be the love interest of the handsome hero, Gervase Frant, Earl of St Erth, I felt … well, cheated is the word that springs to mind. It was as if my beloved GH had conned me out of a beautiful, or at the very least, interesting heroine. The mitigating circumstances, I hear you ask? I was fourteen.   
Drusilla is the daughter of free thinking, academic and deeply radical parents who scorn such accoutrements as titles and hereditary wealth. They are tenants of St Erth and Drusilla is staying with the Dowager Countess at Stanyon when the Earl arrives at his home for the first time since he inherited the title. To say he is not welcome would be an understatement.  
The Earl’s first impression of Drusilla is not favourable. In fact he describes her as having neither countenance nor conversation. As the story unfolds, they become friends and he begins to appreciate her prosaic sayings and common sense approach.  It seems poor Drusilla is destined to have her sensible heart broken when, against every dictate of her own nature and despite her best efforts to the contrary, she tumbles headlong in love with Gervase.  He, on the other hand, has joined the throng of admirers flocking to the side of the lovely Miss Bolderwood.
Here we encounter Drusilla as she ponders her plight:
‘ … a candid scrutiny of her own face in the mirror soon lowered her spirits … She could perceive no merit either in the freshness of her complexion, or in her dark, well-opened eyes, and would willingly have sacrificed the natural curl in her brown hair for tresses of gold, or even of raven-black. As for her figure, though some men might admire little plump women, she could not bring herself to suppose that St Erth, himself so slim and graceful, could think her anything but a poor little dab of a girl. … 'Depend upon it, you are just the sort of girl a man would be glad to have for his sister! You don't even know how to swoon, and I daresay if you tried you would make wretched work of it, for all you have is common-sense, and of what use is that, pray?'
This embittered thought brought to her mind the several occasions upon which she might, had she been the kind of female his lordship no doubt admired, have kindled his ardour by a display of sensibility, or even of heroism. This excursion into romance was not entirely successful, for while she did her best to conjure up an agreeable vision of a heroic Miss Morville, the Miss Morville who was the possessor not only of a practical mind but also of two outspoken brothers could not but interpose objections to the heroine's actions. … 'You would do better to put him out of your mind, and return to your parents,' she said. 'No doubt he will presently become betrothed to a tall and beautiful woman, and forget your very existence.
Having re-read The Quiet Gentleman many times since I was fourteen, I now count Drusilla as one of my favourite heroines.  Along with Hesther Theale (Sprig Muslin), she has me rooting for the ‘ordinary’ girl. And she makes me laugh.
My favourite Drusilla-isms are her comments on some famous academics of the day:
Mrs William Godwin, née Mary Wollstonecraft, is a former friend of Mrs Morville. Drusilla recounts a story about her attempting suicide by casting herself into the Thames at Putney. In her inimitable way, Drusilla states that she had planned to do it at Battersea but it was too crowded there.
Mary Wollstonecraft was an English author and feminist who wrote a Vindication of the Rights of Women in 1792, the first great feminist document. She married William Godwin in 1797 and died in childbirth. Her daughter Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley wrote Frankenstein.
Miss Mary Lamb was described by Drusilla as having ‘murdered her mama in a fit of aberration’. Drusilla was using this example as an illustration of how highly intellectual people can be capable of violent acts.
Mary Lamb along with her brother Charles Lamb was the noted author of Tales from Shakespeare, a children's book. She was considered mentally ill and did, indeed, murder her mother.
One of my recent flights of fancy has been to imagine an Agony Aunt column written by a Heyer heroine. It would have to be one of GH’s self-styled ‘managing females’. Probably Sophy, Frederica or Drusilla.
‘Dearest Drusilla’ … it has a ring to it, doesn’t it?  
So, when faced with a letter from a certain aristocratic red-head residing in Bath who wants advice on her tangled love life ( having jilted an Earl just before her wedding she is now engaged to her first love but realises that, despite their stormy relationship, she is still in love with said Earl), I wonder, What Would Drusilla Do? 

0 Comments

Rating the Romantic Heroes

4/10/2013

2 Comments

 
What makes the perfect romantic hero? 
Maybe I’m biased … but, I quite like one of my own heroes, Jack Lindsey! So I thought I’d see how he shapes up next to my personal Top 5 Romantic heroes of all time (although I’m quite sure everyone’s Top 5 will look different).
I started out with a longer list including Mr Knightley (Emma, Jane Austen), Jasper, Lord Damerel (Venetia, Georgette Heyer), Mark Darcy (Bridget Jones’ Diary, Helen Fielding) and Lord Byron (the only real character to make it onto this list!). I eventually narrowed it down to these 5:

My Top 6 (5 plus Jack!) Romantic Heroes
Book
Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen


Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte

Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier

Jane Eyre by 
Charlotte Bronte

Untitled by Jane Godman

Hero
Rhett Butler

Mr Darcy



Heathcliff


Maxim de Winter


Mr Rochester


Jack Lindsey
Heroine
Scarlett O’Hara

Elizabeth Bennett



Catherine Earnshaw


Unknown


Jane Eyre


Rosie Delacourt
Setting
Atlanta 1860s-70s

England late 18th/early 19th century

Yorkshire approx. 1750-1802


Monte Carlo and England 1920s or 30s

England early 19th century

England and Scotland 1740s

First of all, what are the characteristics of the perfect romantic hero? My hero would be some, and preferably all, of the following:
· Charismatic (he should dominate the page)
· Dangerous, rebellious or edgy (and it helps if he has a dark secret)
· Attractive (not necessarily handsome, but he must be sexy!)
· Confident (even arrogant, he should be an Alpha Male)
· Intelligent (he doesn’t have to have a degree in Quantum Physics, but he should be smart)
Just for fun, I devised a scoring system. I’m not suggesting there is a perfect formula. For example, one of my favourite romantic heroes is Georgette Heyer’s Freddy Standen (and he would end up with a negative score!).
But, bear with me and let’s just see how Jack compares to the all-time greats! The maximum score for each category is 5.
 
How old is he?
It was hard to decide on the ideal age for a romantic hero (and there are lots of
examples of great younger and older heroes). But I decided that a hero aged 28
should score the maximum 5 points. Then I took points away for every 2 years
above or below that.
Hero
Rhett

Mr Darcy
Heathcliff

Maxim
Mr Rochester
Jack

Age
At the start of the novel Scarlett assumes he is about 35. He is actually 33 (because at the end of the book he is 45).
30
The book's timeline is from his childhood to his death. Cathy is 19 when she dies and he is a year or two older
42
Probably late 30s (he is 20 years older than Jane)
26 when the series begins



Score
***

****
*

0
0
****
Is he attractive?
Hero
Rhett

Mr Darcy

Heathcliff

Maxim
Mr Rochester

Jack
Looks
He has dark, good looks and an expression of cynical amusement.
He is a fine, tall person with handsome features and noble mien.
He has thick, low brows, black hair and whiskers. He is athletic and energetic.
He is cultured, handsome and mysterious
He is not handsome. He is stern-featured, heavy-browed and craggy-faced
He has finely-carved, aristocratic features, dark-blonde hair and incredibly blue eyes
Score
*****

*****

***

*****
***

*****
Is he dangerous/edgy/arrogant/does he have a dark secret?
Hero
Rhett

Mr Darcy
Heathcliff

Maxim
Mr Rochester

Jack

Edginess
He is a charming rogue, a war hero who doesn’t scruple to engage in illegal activities.
He is wealthy, proud and aloof.
He is sinister, malevolent, dangerous and brooding.
He is irascible and moody. He has a dark secret.
He is rude, arrogant and moody. He has a dark secret.
He is a swash-buckling rebel lord who is wanted for treason. He also keeps the London gossips busy with his scandalous behaviour.

Score
*****

****
*****

*****
*****

*****
What is his most romantic line?
Hero
Rhett



Mr Darcy
Heathcliff



Maxim


Mr Rochester



Jack
Line
No, I don't think I will kiss you, although you need kissing, badly. That's what's wrong with you. You should be kissed and often, and by someone who knows how.
You have bewitched me, body and soul.
If he loved you with all the power of his soul for a whole lifetime, he couldn’t love you as much as I do in a single day.
It's gone forever, that funny young, lost look I loved won't ever come back.
I sometimes have a queer feeling with regard to you--especially when you are near me, as now: it is as if I had a string somewhere under my left ribs, tightly and inextricably knotted to a similar string situated in the corresponding quarter of your little frame.
You are my addiction. I cannot get enough of you. Try as I will to forget you, you invade my dreams as well as my every waking thought.

Score
****



****
*****


**

*****





***
How romantic was his proposal?
Hero
Rhett



Mr Darcy


Heathcliff

Maxim
Mr Rochester



Jack
Proposal
This is an honorable proposal of marriage made at what I consider a most opportune moment. I can't go all my life waiting to catch you between husbands.
In vain have I struggled. It will not do. My feelings will not be repressed. You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you.
None – he hears Cathy say it would degrade her to marry him.
I’m asking you to marry me, you little fool.
Jane, I want a wife. I want a wife, not a nursemaid to look after me. I want a wife to share my bed every night. All day if we wish. If I can't have that, I'd rather die. We're not the platonic sort, Jane.
Rosie, my heart, my dearest love. I swear that, once I have secured the king’s pardon, I will come back for you and make you my wife. Will you wait for me?

Score
**



***


0

*
*****



**
Final Scores!
Hero
Mr Darcy
Rhett Butler
Jack Lindsey
Mr Rochester
Heathcliff
Maxim de Winter


Score (out of 25)
20
19
19
18
14
13
Hmm, not bad! I can live with Jack in a tie with Rhett Butler (who I think has some of the best romantic lines ever)! Although poor Heathcliff gets a raw deal on this scoring system (since he never actually gets a chance to propose to Cathy!). But then (and do feel free to disagree with me) I see Heathcliff as something of an 'anti-hero'!
I’d love to hear your comments! Are there any characteristics you would include that I’ve missed? What does your Top 5 look like? 
2 Comments

Which Heyer Heroine are you?

4/8/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
Are you Hero or Sophy? Arabella or Judith? Take the quiz below to find out if you should be with Vidal or Sherry!
1. You have recently made the acquaintance of a handsome, eligible gentleman but he has formed a most unfavourable opinion of you. What do you do? 
A Challenge him to a duel…with either swords or pistols. 
B He is such a god-like figure to me, how could I hope to change his opinion? Indeed, why would I want to? 
C Solve all his problems and those of his family, laugh at him, challenge him at every turn, and argue with him. Just generally infuriate him! 
D Make up a daring false identity on the spur of the moment and not give a thought to the consequences. 
E I don’t think he has really noticed me - his gaze seems to look right through me - but I would maintain a dignified distance. 
F Glare at him and try and provoke him into an argument. 
2. Another lady challenges you to a carriage race. How do you respond? 
A No-one would dare challenge me! 
B I would take up the challenge. After all, I want to be thought of as a dashing lady of fashion and I think it would really impress the man I love. 
C Although I know it’s not the done thing, I wouldn’t be able to resist a challenge and it would provide an opportunity to provoke my love rival and infuriate the man I love! 
D I wouldn’t do anything that might draw undue attention to me. If the ton find out I’m an impostor, I’m in more than enough trouble as it is! 
E I’ve never had the opportunity to learn to drive. But the man I love drives at the devil’s own pace and cares nothing for reputation! 
F I’d take up the challenge just to annoy the man I love, but I think I’d regret my actions later. 
3. It is your first appearance in society, and you are being introduced to the polite world. What is their first impression of you? 
A I’m unique…stunningly beautiful and spirited. And there is a mystery attached to me. 
B Well, people are rather shocked by my runaway marriage, but on the whole I’m seen as a sweet, prettily-behaved girl. 
C I’ve spent my whole life in the public eye across Europe. I was born to be a society hostess! My sparkling wit makes up for the fact that I have countenance rather than beauty. 
D I take society by storm because I am so beautiful but also, alas, because everyone believes I am possessed of a large fortune! 
E I expect they will be surprised at my understated looks and quiet manners. The man I love is noted for the dazzling beauties he usually attracts. I hope they never discover the shocking circumstances surrounding my abduction! 
F My beauty is much admired and I have a large fortune, but I can be rather fierce. An attempt to give me an unflattering nickname might almost destroy my reputation but I hope that Mr Brummell would come to my rescue! 
4. The man you love asks for your hand in marriage. How do you react? 
A I tell him he does not need to marry me, I will be his mistress until he tires of me. 
B He’s only asking me so that he can get his hands on his fortune and because the woman he really loves has turned him down. But I love him desperately and it’s better than becoming a governess after all! 
C Well, he said he dislikes me excessively, but I know that means he loves me really! 
D I can’t accept! I love him but I’ve deceived him into thinking I have a large fortune. 
E He is only asking me because he ruined my reputation by abducting me when I pretended to be my sister. I love him but I’ll have to run away. 
F At last! I thought he disliked me and my behaviour had given him a disgust of me but he was waiting until he was no longer my guardian. 
5. You have been abducted. What do you do? 
A Escape, of course! 
B It’s only my husband, isn’t it? Isn’t it? 
C I can’t imagine anyone trying to abduct me! Although, I did pretend that Lord Charlbury abducted me, but that was part of a plan… 
D It’s never happened to me. I expect I would befriend someone and ask them for help. 
E Shoot my abductor to protect my virtue. 
F Lose my temper with my abductor but secretly be nervous and hope that my guardian will rescue me. 
6. What sort of men are attracted to you? 
A Dashing young bucks. Oh, and a prince of the realm! 
B Mostly loose screws who think they can take advantage of my innocence but also a kind, considerate older neighbour. Oh dear, I think I may have misled him! 
C Dashing military men and those I flirted with while abroad. 
D Most men seem to find me attractive … but I suspect that is because they believe I have a large fortune! 
E My staid cousin has always been my most ardent suitor until I met the dashing marquis who captured my heart! 
F My guardian has had to depress the pretensions of many suitors who would like to get their hands on my fortune, including a royal duke! 

Mostly A You are like Leonie de Saint Vire (These Old Shades). Fiercely loyal, you have had to look after yourself from a very young age and it shows. You'd rather have a sword fight than do needlework and you fight against the restraints imposed on women. You have a quick temper and will fiercely defend the ones you love even at a personal cost. Whether you are in the ragged clothes of a Paris urchin, or in your rightful finery, you stun others with your beauty and courage. 

Mostly B You are like Hero Wantage (Friday’s Child). Sweet natured, faithful and patient, you hero-worship the man of your dreams from a distance. You know he will never love you in return but you are content to be there for him. You attract friends – male and female - easily and people confide in you. You are naïve and trusting and some people try to take advantage of your good nature. Even so, you never make the same mistake twice and are quick to learn. 

Mostly C You are like Sophy Staton-Lacy (The Grand Sophy). Strong, determined and humorous, you are more than capable of sorting out any challenges that come your way ... or anyone else's way! You will go to any lengths to help your friends and family when they need it, and you overcome all obstacles with confidence and creativity. You have a heart of gold. Such is your charm that even frequent fights and an annoying fiancé don’t stop the man you love from falling for you. 

Mostly D You are like Arabella Tallant (Arabella). You are beautiful, charming and strong-willed, and are always considerate of those less fortunate than you. You will stand up for what is right even in the face of possible condemnation from the ton. Your simple style and prettiness make you popular with everyone you meet. You are impulsive to a fault and this can lead you into trouble. You hate injustice and woe betide the man who jumps to the wrong conclusion about you! 

Mostly E You are like Mary Challoner (Devil’s Cub). You are dignified, stylish and witty and you have a strong sense of humour. Your belief in duty leads you to take drastic steps to protect your family. You are very well educated and this can lead some people to believe you are unapproachable. Your courage is remarkable and you stand up to danger calmly. You are not one to be intimidated. When you fall in love you surprise everyone by choosing a rogue, but you know you can handle him! 

Mostly F You are like Judith Taverner (Regency Buck). Beautiful, strong-willed and feisty, you will have none of this nonsense about conforming to what society wants! Sometimes you let your temper get the better of you, but common sense usually prevails in the end. You fight against the restraints imposed by convention but you are secretly glad to have the protection of a strong man. You enjoy a good argument! Fashionable society appeals to you because you enjoy being a trendsetter.

0 Comments
    Picture
    Welcome to my blog. This is where I write about my own books and about things related to my books. Please be aware that everything is copyrighted and may be intended for an adult audience. Anyone under the age of eighteen should not proceed. ​
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Blog Archives

    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

✕